An intensive functionary campaign took precedence over the presentation of electoral lists
Transparency Serbia’s monitoring shows that the intensive official campaign on the eve of the June parliamentary elections overshadowed the presentation of the list of participants in the elections. Although it is an election for MPs, the media scene was dominated by the promotion of Aleksandar Vucic through paid advertising, guest appearances on TV shows, and his moderate presence in promotional events, which were highly well-placed in the media. There were also many promotional activities of other officials who did not miss the opportunity to mention Aleksandar Vučić. At the same time, local officials did not lack promotions.
The President, the Prime Minister (Brnabic), two Deputy Prime Ministers (Mihajlovic and Dacic) and three ministers (Vulin, Sarcevic and Djordjevic) had a total of 173 promotional events during the 50 days of the campaign (ending on 17 June), which is about 50% more than during the same period in 2019. It is worth reminding that in that period, the number of promotional events was extremely high due to the promotional tour of the President of Serbia – “Future of Serbia”, in which other public officials also participated.
In the entire election campaign, not counting the activities during the covid-related state of emergency “break” period, Brnabic and Vulin had 34 promotional activities each, Sarcevic and Djordjevic 25 each, Mihajlovic 22, Dacic17 and president Vucic 17.
However, promotional activities did not stop even during the state of emergency, when Vulin had an additional 52, Djordjevic 29, and Vucic 11.
Aleksandar Vucic was dominant on the front pages of the press (11 national and regional dailies). He has appeared 324 times since 6 March until today (including the state of the emergency period): 275 times in a positive context, 20 in a neutral context and 29 in a negative one. He was the central theme in a positive context 113 times.
Other officials of the ruling party (SNS) and the parties from the list led by Vucic had 99 appearances on the front pages, 92 in a positive context. In a negative context, Vucic and the SNS found themselves only on the front pages of the daily “Danas” (in the previous election cycle, the daily “Vesti” also showed a critical attitude).
The second in terms of the number of appearances is Dragan Djilas with 102, of which 90 in a negative context, of which 37 times as the main topic. Vuk Jeremic and Bosko Obradovic can boast of 54 covers, of which 41 were in a negative context.
Ivica Dacic and other officials from the SPS-JS coalition list found themselves on 49 front pages, of which 28 with positive, five neutral and 16 negative appearances.
The SNS advertising campaign was completely personified in Vucic. Although he is the president of Serbia, the 21 June elections are not presidential elections. Vucic, of course, is not on the SNS list, but one promotional video still says - “Vote for the man who works for our children - Aleksandar Vucic for our children”.
The President of Serbia’s participation in the functionary campaign has intensified in the last days before the election silence. Although the number of promotional events he plays a part in is lower than in the case of other officials, they are much more visible in the media.
On the other hand, all other officials – the prime minister, deputy prime ministers, ministers, local officials, public enterprises leaders – most often thank Aleksandar Vucic in their speeches for everything achieved or started, for ideas and initiatives, thus closing the context set through election advertising.
At the same time, the campaign for local elections is being carried out through the functionary campaign of the highest officials because, in the company of state officials (members of the government, directors of national public companies), mayors and local officials participate in promotional activities.
A similar situation is for public enterprises: an illustrative example is the EPS acting director’s promotional activities with the mayors in the last ten days of the campaign.
In the pre-election segments, TV stations do not present the programmes of the electoral lists but let them present themselves through the submitted recorded material. It is noticeable that there was almost no representation of the ruling SNS party in those segments, or the local party committees’ activities were presented.
There was practically no need for presentation of SNS since in the central news on TV stations with a national frequency, reports about the activities of Vucic, who is the central figure of the SNS in the campaign at all election levels, and news about the activities of ministers occupy a significant part. In addition to reports about Vucic promotional activities, he also appears in information about other topics – through statements given during promotional activities on other current issues.
The following example testifies to the dominance of the functionary campaign in relation to the “equal representation of all participants” in special election segments: in one observed day, at the beginning of the campaign, in the central news programmes of five TV stations (RTS, Prva, Pink, N1 and Studio B), Aleksandar Vucic was present for 2580 seconds, in a total of 11 reports; Sarcevic 180, Ana Brnabic 105, Ivica Dacic 57. All other officials were represented in 1169 seconds, with the city and municipal officials given the most of that time in Studio B central news. On the other hand, the election segments lasted only 1253 seconds in all five main news.
An extreme case is TV Pink, where Vucic dominates in the first part of the leading news. The SNS does not appear in the following election segment, but then often comes a special report broadcasting a complete recording of Vucic speech at a promotional event that day. After that, another news segment follows featuring other government officials.
We emphasise that the data of the current cross-section of the situation are presented here for the national officials who were the most prominent during the campaign. We will present complete findings of our monitoring of the campaign of 30 officials (both at the national and local level), together with concrete examples of the functionary campaign and examples of violations of the law, data on reports submitted by Transparency Serbia, analysis of individual bodies’ activities, analysis of front pages and central news of the five TV stations, in the week after the election.
News
Proposals for the implementation of ODIHR recommendations and improvement of election conditions
Transparency Serbia has used the opportunity to present to representatives of parliamentary parties and the Working Group of the Government of Serbia for Cooperation with ODIHR a number of specific proposals and priorities for improving election conditions, especially regarding the financing of the election campaign and preventing the misuse of…
... detaljnije ...TS submitted proposals to the Assembly for the implementation of recommendations from the ODIHR report
Transparency Serbia submitted to the Serbian Parliament and the Government Working Group for the Improvement of the Electoral Process proposals regarding the implementation of certain recommendations from the Final ODIHR report after the December 2023 elections and unfulfilled recommendations after the previous elections. TS informed the ODIHR Observation Mission, the citizens…
... detaljnije ...Ministry of Interior should publish data on migration of voters that it submitted to Prime Minister
The claim of the Prime Minister in the technical mandate, according to which "everyone can check" in how many cases citizens change their residence, not only does not correspond to the factual situation but is directly opposite to the official answer that Transparency Serbia received from the Ministry of Internal…
... detaljnije ...Corruption prevention in the executive branch - useful GRECO recommendations have not yet been implemented
If Serbia were to implement the recommendations it received in March 2022 from GRECO (Group of Countries for Combating Corruption) – a body established by the Council of Europe – it would significantly improve the mechanisms for combating corruption in the work of the executive. However, very little has been…
... detaljnije ...ODIHR calls for improvement of campaign finance rules and prevention of abuse of public resources "well in advance of the…
In the final Report on the December elections, the ODIHR observation mission confirmed some of the findings of Transparency Serbia's monitoring of the election campaign, and a large number of recommendations refer to unresolved issues of election campaign financing, misuse of public resources and participation of public officials in the…
... detaljnije ...The costs of the Belgrade local election campaign - what is shown and what is missing
Although there were 14 election lists in the Belgrade local elections, and the deadline for submitting the final financial reports expired six days ago, only nine lists have been published so far. According to the information published on the Agency for the Prevention of Corruption website, the report on the…
... detaljnije ...Procurement for EXPO 2027 - no minimum deadlines and no legal protection
The Government of Serbia adopted a decree which, in accordance with the lex specialis, prescribes how procurement will be carried out and jobs awarded for EXPO 2027. Nemanja Nenadić from Transparency Serbia for N1 says that the differences between the rules prescribed by the Law on Public Procurement and this…
... detaljnije ...Serbia continues to fall on global list of Transparency International's Corruption Perception Index
In Serbia, there is no political will to reduce corruption; the Government bypasses laws on public procurement, passes special laws for multimillion-projects that are important to it, does not adopt an anti-corruption strategy, and is increasingly distant from the rule of law. It was said at the Transparency of Serbia…
... detaljnije ...TS calls on MIA and HPPO to publish additional information on their actions regarding election irregularities
The information presented to the public by the Ministry of Internal Affairs (MIA), the Ministry of State Administration and Local Self-Government (MSALSG), as well as the Higher Public Prosecutor's Office (HPPO) in Belgrade, regarding allegations of illegality in the electoral list and vote buying, are not sufficient to dispel publicly…
... detaljnije ...Alarm over indications of serious election breaches
Transparency International urgently calls on the Serbian authorities to investigate potential abuses of public office and resources by the ruling party during the 17 December elections. It is also crucial to swiftly determine whether vote-buying took place. The prosecution and the Agency for Prevention of Corruption (APC) need to promptly…
... detaljnije ...
In the election campaign, blurred line between state and the party - a sharp and valuable report by ODIHR
The observation mission of the ODIHR already in the preliminary Report highlighted not only the shortcomings of legal solutions but also numerous severe violations of the law during the campaign and election day, among which are problems for which Transparency Serbia has been proposing concrete solutions for years. The International Election…
... detaljnije ...Unfulfilled obligations and priorities for the fight against corruption
The International Anti-Corruption Day, 9 December, is a good reason to call on the Parliament and the Government, which will be formed after the upcoming elections, to finally adopt one of the most effective mechanisms for the fight against corruption - the introduction of illegal enrichment, as a criminal offence…
... detaljnije ...EC report – benevolent conclusion on progress and numerous unresolved problems
The European Commission's assessment[1] of Serbia's "limited progress" in the fight against corruption is too benevolent. On the other hand, the EC report is significant, as it points to some of the most important unresolved issues, including direct contracting of procurement for infrastructure projects, illegal acting state in public administration…
... detaljnije ...The work of temporary bodies during the election campaign must be transparent
Transparency Serbia has indicated to the presidents and members of temporary working bodies in 65 cities and municipalities that they have an obligation to ensure the publicity of their work by allowing journalists to attend the sessions and publishing the explanations for the decisions they make. Based on the Law on…
... detaljnije ...Violations marked the introduction to local elections
Information about the fact that the leaders of around 70 cities and municipalities submitted their resignations – meaning their mandate ended – cannot be found on the Agency for the Prevention of Corruption website. It means that the assemblies of these cities and municipalities violated the legal obligation. An even bigger…
... detaljnije ...The amendment to the Law on Electronic Media does not solve the problem of "public officials' campaign"
The provision of the Law on Electronic Media, passed today, even with the amendment that was adopted by the Parliamentary Information Committee – allegedly to fulfil the ODIHR recommendation – does not solve the problems related to the promotional activities of public officials and does not represent the fulfilment of…
... detaljnije ...An amendment to prevent procurement for EXPO 2027 from being conducted without applying the Law on Public Procurement
Transparency Serbia has submitted to parliamentary groups in the Parliament of Serbia a proposal for an amendment to the Special Law on EXPO 2027 that would remove one of the significant corruption risks by obliging the special companies that will be formed for the implementation of the project to apply…
... detaljnije ...Novi Pazar, Sombor and Veliko Gradište the Most Transparent Local Governments in 2023
Novi Pazar, Sombor and Veliko Gradište are the most transparent local governments in 2023 according to the Local Transparency Index published today by Transparency Serbia, with support from the United States Agency for International Development (USAID). Since 2015, the Index has been measuring the transparency of all 145 local governments…
... detaljnije ...No public procurement for EXPO 2027 project
Works for the construction of the exhibition area for EXPO 2027, facilities for the accommodation of participants and visitors, the National Stadium and supporting infrastructure – the value of which could amount to one billion euros – will be contracted without the application of the Law on Public Procurement, which…
... detaljnije ...Which Local Governments Were the Most Transparent in Serbia in 2023?
On October 13, 2023, Transparency Serbia and the United States Agency for International Development (USAID) will present the results of the 2023 Local Transparency Index (LTI). The Index has been measuring the transparency of all 145 local governments and 25 city municipalities in Serbia each year since 2015 and tracks…
... detaljnije ...
EPS illegally withholds information
EPS AD (Electric Power Company of Serbia), joint stock company unlawfully withholds essential information from the public about its work and the possible disposing of the assets of great value. Transparency Serbia, since 26 May 2023, has been trying to verify with the Electric Power Company of Serbia the allegations…
... detaljnije ...On amendments to the Law on Prevention of Corruption
The draft amendments to the Law on the Prevention of Corruption[1], presented for public discussion, respond to the GRECO's recommendations for Serbia[2] to a limited extent. On the other hand, it does not contain measures to reduce the scope of the "official campaign" and to increase the capacity of control…
... detaljnije ...The new draft law on the management of state-owned enterprises still needs amendments
The new proposal of the Law on the Management of Public Enterprises Owned by the Republic of Serbia is better than the previously withdrawn one. Still, it also needs to be amended, primarily in the area related to preventing misuse of public resources during the election campaign, transitional provisions and…
... detaljnije ...Corrupt risks of free conversion not taken into account
Amendments to the Law on Planning and Construction carry a high corruption risk because the state is giving up potential public revenues in favour of individual companies and, at the same time, threatens legal certainty and equality before the law. The amendments provide for the free conversion of the "right of…
... detaljnije ...What needs to be fixed in the proposal of the law on the management of state enterprises
Transparency Serbia sent the Government of Serbia, the Ministry of Economy and the Agency for the Prevention of Corruption a detailed analysis of corruption risks and other shortcomings in the draft law on managing business companies owned by the Republic of Serbia (SOE). The proposal for a law on companies owned…
... detaljnije ...Directors of SOE outside the reach of anti-corruption regulations
The directors of the largest state-owned companies (SOE), which manage assets worth tens of billions of euros, will not have the obligations, restrictions or control provided for public officials in the Law on Prevention of Corruption if the deputies adopt the proposed Law on the Management of Companies Owned by…
... detaljnije ...One of the laws crumbling the public procurement system repealed
The repeal of the law on line infrastructure[1], which opened up a huge space for discretionary decision-making and had the potential for corruption, is good news after years of crumbling public procurement systems. However, it is essential to emphasize that by deleting this law, only one of the channels for…
... detaljnije ...Change the selection method for independent bodies' managers
The legal rules leave too much room for political parties to influence the election of heads of independent bodies, Transparency Serbia emphasises. Although the majority of MPs decide the election - which is inevitable - the parties also have the sole or decisive say in the candidacy phase. At today's session…
... detaljnije ...Harmful and unexplained amendments to the Statute of ”JP Elektroprivreda Srbije”
Amendments to the articles of founding act and the Statute of ”JP Elektroprivreda Srbije” will have very harmful consequences on the implementation of anti-corruption laws in the largest Serbian public company, Transparency Serbia warns. In addition, the key reasons for changes are not explained and the legal basis is disputed. The…
... detaljnije ...Prosecutor's Office should increase the transparency of its work and investigate all abuses in EPS
The Higher Public Prosecutor's Office (HPPO) in Belgrade, in response to a request for access to information sent by Transparency Serbia, confirmed[1] that there is no evidence that prosecutor Bojana Savović requested a transfer from the Special Department for the Fight against Corruption. At the same time, HPPO did not submit…
... detaljnije ...
- 1
- 2
- 3