ODIHR calls for improvement of campaign finance rules and prevention of abuse of public resources "well in advance of the next election"
In the final Report on the December elections, the ODIHR observation mission confirmed some of the findings of Transparency Serbia's monitoring of the election campaign, and a large number of recommendations refer to unresolved issues of election campaign financing, misuse of public resources and participation of public officials in the campaign.
The Final Report of the OSCE Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights (ODIHR) on the elections in Serbia held on 17 December 2023, contains 25 current recommendations and a reminder of numerous unfulfilled and partially fulfilled recommendations from earlier reports. If the Government of Serbia decides to act on ODIHR's recommendations this time, instead of ignoring them – as was the case after the 2022 election – the success of that endeavour should be evaluated by looking at both new and all previous recommendations that were not fully fulfilled.
Among the earlier non-fulfilled recommendations, some requested a significant improvement of regulations and practices related to the financing of election campaigns, regulation of official campaigns, prevention of abuse of public resources, and pressure on voters.
For seven years, in all election cycles, ODIHR has been repeating or reminding of the failure to fulfil the recommendation that it is necessary to strictly separate the performance of public office from party activities and adhere to that division in order to ensure equal opportunities for election participants.
Since 2017, it has also been repeated that state authorities must take decisive measures to prevent pressure on voters, including public sector employees, and that the cases of pressure must be thoroughly investigated and the responsible individuals punished.
Among the unfulfilled "old" recommendations is the introduction of expenditure limits in the election campaign, which, unlike most of the neighbouring countries, do not exist in Serbia. It further deepens the unequal position of the election contestants. TS proposes that the maximum allowed campaign costs per electoral list or presidential candidate be RSD 300 million (about € 2.5 million). ODIHR has also previously indicated that campaign budget money should be paid out at the beginning of the campaign, not immediately before or after the election.
The most important ODIHR recommendation is general - that all changes in the regulations should be implemented well in advance of the next elections through an "inclusive consultative procedure" based on a "broad political consensus". ODIHR also emphasized that the Government's Working Group for the implementation of recommendations should act in full transparency and include civil society organizations. In this regard, TS reminds that this Working Group did not publish information about its work at all from April 2021 to October 2023 and that the last consultations with civil society were held in March 2021.
Probably the most controversial issue of the December elections – voter migration – is primarily significant for Belgrade and other local elections, which ODIHR did not monitor. Nevertheless, it is significant that despite that fact, a recommendation to eliminate doubts and increase confidence in the correctness of voter registration found its place in the Report. In order to achieve the same goal, Transparency Serbia proposed to the Ministry of Internal Affairs (MIA) to publish anonymized data not only on the state but also on the movement of citizens' residences (municipality of previous and new residence and dates of registration). The MIA claims in its response that "in the available records ...it is not possible to perform a search according to the specified criteria". Since the issue of organized relocation of voters is of great importance for the upcoming spring local elections in more than half of the Serbian cities and municipalities, it is necessary to open a discussion on possible ways to prevent abuses immediately.
Regarding the functionary campaign, this time, ODIHR requested that the law establish a clear separation between the exercise of official functions and the campaigning activities of the incumbents. As part of the same recommendation, ODIHR indicated that state authorities should take measures to prevent the misuse of public functions and public resources and also detect and punish these phenomena proactively. Also, ODIHR specified that the observers hired by the Agency for the Prevention of Corruption should monitor not only the activities of political entities but also those of public officials.
Even during this election campaign, the public prosecutor's office and the Agency for the Prevention of Corruption did not investigate numerous suspicions of misuse and non-separation of public office and pre-election promotions. Moreover, the legality of the officials' actions was not ensured in a timely manner, even through the acting on complaints. Thus, even after three months, citizens of Serbia do not know whether, in the opinion of the Agency, ministers Vesić and Martinović promoted their party's electoral list by using public resources, as TS indicated in its complaint. ODIHR, in its Report, recommends that amendments to the Law on Prevention of Corruption prescribe that the Agency must publish decisions related to violations of the Law on Prevention of Corruption within a short period, as is currently the case for applications concerning breaches of the Law on Financing of Political Activities.
Although the ODIHR Report states that the "decisive involvement of the President of the Republic" was one of the key factors that led to unfair campaign conditions, according to the Agency, the President of the Republic and the holder of the winning electoral list did not, in any case, violate his legal duty to clearly present to interlocutors and the public in which capacity he acts. All this clearly shows that the problem pointed out by the ODIHR cannot be solved by some additional clarification of the rules about "separation of roles" or the rules for media representation, but only by introducing a legal restriction on the promotional activities that public officials can undertake in that capacity in the period before the elections. Transparency Serbia has offered concrete solutions for amending Article 50 of the Law on Prevention of Corruption.
Concerning the financing of the campaign, ODIHR, in addition to reminding the recommendations given after the previous elections, particularly pointed out a non-regulated problem of the participation of "third parties" in the campaign. Examples include negative campaigns through unsigned posters, as well as the case of the SNS call centre, which CINS previously wrote about. Regarding this issue, TS highlights that the December elections showed that some expenses, clearly part of the election campaign, are treated as if it were an unregulated "third-party campaign". The most obvious example is the advertising of the SNS candidate for mayor of Belgrade, Aleksandar Šapić, worth almost € 40,000, which is not presented as part of the SNS expenditure for the election campaign.
ODIHR indicated that the Administrative Court should use "all available means" so that legal remedies in election procedures are effective. Related to this, TS reminds that for some disputes related to elections under the jurisdiction of the Administrative Court, there is not even a prescribed deadline for action. As a result, the Administrative Court has not yet decided on the complaint filed by Transparency Serbia against the Agency's decisions on applications, which refer to the 2020 elections.
News
Missed opportunities for the prevention of corruption within the executive authority and the police
GRECO's assessment that Serbia has fulfilled only one of the 24 recommendations from the fifth round of evaluation in two years calls into question the existence of strategic commitment and will to combat corruption, but also confirms the findings of the TS from the beginning of this year. The lack of…
... detaljnije ...Conference: How to prevent waste of public resources
Transparency Serbia (TS) and the Center for Investigative Journalism of Serbia (CINS) invite you to the conference: How to prevent waste of public resources Belgrade, Tuesday, 9 July 2024, 10.00 – 12.00 Envoy Congress Center, Gospodar Jevremova 47 Agenda: 10.00 – 10.05 Nemanja Nenadić, Program Director, Transparency Serbia 10.05 – 10.10 Milica Šarić, Director…
... detaljnije ...Serbia remains among the countries with limited budget transparency
Serbia ranks 55th out of 125 countries in the Open Budget Index (OBI) with 51 points out of a possible 100, which labels it as the country with "limited budget transparency", according to Transparency Serbia. Progress of five points compared to the previous survey (from 2021) was achieved solely due to…
... detaljnije ...Proposals for the implementation of ODIHR recommendations and improvement of election conditions
Transparency Serbia has used the opportunity to present to representatives of parliamentary parties and the Working Group of the Government of Serbia for Cooperation with ODIHR a number of specific proposals and priorities for improving election conditions, especially regarding the financing of the election campaign and preventing the misuse of…
... detaljnije ...TS submitted proposals to the Assembly for the implementation of recommendations from the ODIHR report
Transparency Serbia submitted to the Serbian Parliament and the Government Working Group for the Improvement of the Electoral Process proposals regarding the implementation of certain recommendations from the Final ODIHR report after the December 2023 elections and unfulfilled recommendations after the previous elections. TS informed the ODIHR Observation Mission, the citizens…
... detaljnije ...Ministry of Interior should publish data on migration of voters that it submitted to Prime Minister
The claim of the Prime Minister in the technical mandate, according to which "everyone can check" in how many cases citizens change their residence, not only does not correspond to the factual situation but is directly opposite to the official answer that Transparency Serbia received from the Ministry of Internal…
... detaljnije ...Corruption prevention in the executive branch - useful GRECO recommendations have not yet been implemented
If Serbia were to implement the recommendations it received in March 2022 from GRECO (Group of Countries for Combating Corruption) – a body established by the Council of Europe – it would significantly improve the mechanisms for combating corruption in the work of the executive. However, very little has been…
... detaljnije ...ODIHR calls for improvement of campaign finance rules and prevention of abuse of public resources "well in advance of the…
In the final Report on the December elections, the ODIHR observation mission confirmed some of the findings of Transparency Serbia's monitoring of the election campaign, and a large number of recommendations refer to unresolved issues of election campaign financing, misuse of public resources and participation of public officials in the…
... detaljnije ...The costs of the Belgrade local election campaign - what is shown and what is missing
Although there were 14 election lists in the Belgrade local elections, and the deadline for submitting the final financial reports expired six days ago, only nine lists have been published so far. According to the information published on the Agency for the Prevention of Corruption website, the report on the…
... detaljnije ...Procurement for EXPO 2027 - no minimum deadlines and no legal protection
The Government of Serbia adopted a decree which, in accordance with the lex specialis, prescribes how procurement will be carried out and jobs awarded for EXPO 2027. Nemanja Nenadić from Transparency Serbia for N1 says that the differences between the rules prescribed by the Law on Public Procurement and this…
... detaljnije ...
Serbia continues to fall on global list of Transparency International's Corruption Perception Index
In Serbia, there is no political will to reduce corruption; the Government bypasses laws on public procurement, passes special laws for multimillion-projects that are important to it, does not adopt an anti-corruption strategy, and is increasingly distant from the rule of law. It was said at the Transparency of Serbia…
... detaljnije ...TS calls on MIA and HPPO to publish additional information on their actions regarding election irregularities
The information presented to the public by the Ministry of Internal Affairs (MIA), the Ministry of State Administration and Local Self-Government (MSALSG), as well as the Higher Public Prosecutor's Office (HPPO) in Belgrade, regarding allegations of illegality in the electoral list and vote buying, are not sufficient to dispel publicly…
... detaljnije ...Alarm over indications of serious election breaches
Transparency International urgently calls on the Serbian authorities to investigate potential abuses of public office and resources by the ruling party during the 17 December elections. It is also crucial to swiftly determine whether vote-buying took place. The prosecution and the Agency for Prevention of Corruption (APC) need to promptly…
... detaljnije ...In the election campaign, blurred line between state and the party - a sharp and valuable report by ODIHR
The observation mission of the ODIHR already in the preliminary Report highlighted not only the shortcomings of legal solutions but also numerous severe violations of the law during the campaign and election day, among which are problems for which Transparency Serbia has been proposing concrete solutions for years. The International Election…
... detaljnije ...Unfulfilled obligations and priorities for the fight against corruption
The International Anti-Corruption Day, 9 December, is a good reason to call on the Parliament and the Government, which will be formed after the upcoming elections, to finally adopt one of the most effective mechanisms for the fight against corruption - the introduction of illegal enrichment, as a criminal offence…
... detaljnije ...EC report – benevolent conclusion on progress and numerous unresolved problems
The European Commission's assessment[1] of Serbia's "limited progress" in the fight against corruption is too benevolent. On the other hand, the EC report is significant, as it points to some of the most important unresolved issues, including direct contracting of procurement for infrastructure projects, illegal acting state in public administration…
... detaljnije ...The work of temporary bodies during the election campaign must be transparent
Transparency Serbia has indicated to the presidents and members of temporary working bodies in 65 cities and municipalities that they have an obligation to ensure the publicity of their work by allowing journalists to attend the sessions and publishing the explanations for the decisions they make. Based on the Law on…
... detaljnije ...Violations marked the introduction to local elections
Information about the fact that the leaders of around 70 cities and municipalities submitted their resignations – meaning their mandate ended – cannot be found on the Agency for the Prevention of Corruption website. It means that the assemblies of these cities and municipalities violated the legal obligation. An even bigger…
... detaljnije ...The amendment to the Law on Electronic Media does not solve the problem of "public officials' campaign"
The provision of the Law on Electronic Media, passed today, even with the amendment that was adopted by the Parliamentary Information Committee – allegedly to fulfil the ODIHR recommendation – does not solve the problems related to the promotional activities of public officials and does not represent the fulfilment of…
... detaljnije ...An amendment to prevent procurement for EXPO 2027 from being conducted without applying the Law on Public Procurement
Transparency Serbia has submitted to parliamentary groups in the Parliament of Serbia a proposal for an amendment to the Special Law on EXPO 2027 that would remove one of the significant corruption risks by obliging the special companies that will be formed for the implementation of the project to apply…
... detaljnije ...
Novi Pazar, Sombor and Veliko Gradište the Most Transparent Local Governments in 2023
Novi Pazar, Sombor and Veliko Gradište are the most transparent local governments in 2023 according to the Local Transparency Index published today by Transparency Serbia, with support from the United States Agency for International Development (USAID). Since 2015, the Index has been measuring the transparency of all 145 local governments…
... detaljnije ...No public procurement for EXPO 2027 project
Works for the construction of the exhibition area for EXPO 2027, facilities for the accommodation of participants and visitors, the National Stadium and supporting infrastructure – the value of which could amount to one billion euros – will be contracted without the application of the Law on Public Procurement, which…
... detaljnije ...Which Local Governments Were the Most Transparent in Serbia in 2023?
On October 13, 2023, Transparency Serbia and the United States Agency for International Development (USAID) will present the results of the 2023 Local Transparency Index (LTI). The Index has been measuring the transparency of all 145 local governments and 25 city municipalities in Serbia each year since 2015 and tracks…
... detaljnije ...EPS illegally withholds information
EPS AD (Electric Power Company of Serbia), joint stock company unlawfully withholds essential information from the public about its work and the possible disposing of the assets of great value. Transparency Serbia, since 26 May 2023, has been trying to verify with the Electric Power Company of Serbia the allegations…
... detaljnije ...On amendments to the Law on Prevention of Corruption
The draft amendments to the Law on the Prevention of Corruption[1], presented for public discussion, respond to the GRECO's recommendations for Serbia[2] to a limited extent. On the other hand, it does not contain measures to reduce the scope of the "official campaign" and to increase the capacity of control…
... detaljnije ...The new draft law on the management of state-owned enterprises still needs amendments
The new proposal of the Law on the Management of Public Enterprises Owned by the Republic of Serbia is better than the previously withdrawn one. Still, it also needs to be amended, primarily in the area related to preventing misuse of public resources during the election campaign, transitional provisions and…
... detaljnije ...Corrupt risks of free conversion not taken into account
Amendments to the Law on Planning and Construction carry a high corruption risk because the state is giving up potential public revenues in favour of individual companies and, at the same time, threatens legal certainty and equality before the law. The amendments provide for the free conversion of the "right of…
... detaljnije ...What needs to be fixed in the proposal of the law on the management of state enterprises
Transparency Serbia sent the Government of Serbia, the Ministry of Economy and the Agency for the Prevention of Corruption a detailed analysis of corruption risks and other shortcomings in the draft law on managing business companies owned by the Republic of Serbia (SOE). The proposal for a law on companies owned…
... detaljnije ...Directors of SOE outside the reach of anti-corruption regulations
The directors of the largest state-owned companies (SOE), which manage assets worth tens of billions of euros, will not have the obligations, restrictions or control provided for public officials in the Law on Prevention of Corruption if the deputies adopt the proposed Law on the Management of Companies Owned by…
... detaljnije ...One of the laws crumbling the public procurement system repealed
The repeal of the law on line infrastructure[1], which opened up a huge space for discretionary decision-making and had the potential for corruption, is good news after years of crumbling public procurement systems. However, it is essential to emphasize that by deleting this law, only one of the channels for…
... detaljnije ...
- 1
- 2
- 3